Which Metal is Best for Your Engagement Ring?

Choosing the right metal for your engagement ring is more than just a design decision—it impacts durability, comfort, and even how your diamond shines. In this article, Benjamin Khordipour, a GIA Gemologist, renowned author, and celebrity jeweler, shares expert insights to help you pick the perfect metal that suits your style and stands the test of time.

Skip to the bottom to read our top insider tips for which metal to pick!

Which Metal is Best for the Engagement Rings?

After decades in the jewelry business, and weighing every pro and con, we believe that platinum is the best metal for an engagement ring. That being said, it could be that you have other considerations that will make another metal a better choice for you.

Keep reading to discover which metal is best for your specific needs.

Comparing Metals for the Engagement Ring

Every metal has its own personality—color, shine, strength, and price all play a role. Gold and platinum remain the most popular, while metals like palladium or titanium offer modern alternatives. Even gold comes in different karats, each with its own mix of purity and durability.

“When it comes to engagement rings,” says Afshin Shaddaie, “choosing the type of metal is almost as important as selecting the right diamond.”

Knowing how each metal looks, wears, and can be resized will help you choose wisely. Maybe you love the lasting elegance of platinum, the soft blush of rose gold, or the clean look of white gold. Whatever your style, the right choice will be one that feels timeless and works for your lifestyle.

Here’s a breakdown on the most popular metal options, its cost per ounce, hardness and popularity.

Metal	Cost per Ounce	Hardness Grading	Popularity Score
24K Gold	$3,286	Soft	2/10
18K Gold	$2,465	Medium	10/10
14K Gold	$1,922	Hard	7/10
Platinum	$1,353	Very Hard	10/10
Palladium	$1,151	Very Hard	7/10
Titanium	$800	Very Hard	6/10
Sterling Silver	$36	Soft	4/10

We will now go through each metal and explain how to use it for your engagement ring and its pros and cons.

24 Karat Gold Engagement Ring

24K gold is as pure as it gets—99.9% gold with no added alloys. It comes from the earth in its natural, bright yellow form. Its rich color and shine are unmatched, but it’s also very soft, which makes it less practical for engagement rings. Jewelers often need to reinforce it or use special designs to give it enough strength.

Typical Cost for Mounting: A 24K gold engagement ring mounting usually costs between $1,200 and $2,000. This price covers the setting only, not the center stone or any side gems.

Because it’s pure, 24K gold holds its value extremely well, making it appealing for resale or investment. Just keep in mind that while the metal’s value stays high, the labor cost for craftsmanship is rarely recovered.

Pros: Hypoallergenic and won’t tarnish, Deep vibrant yellow color, and high intrinsic value due to its purity.

Cons: Very soft and prone to scratching or bending, not ideal for complex designs because of its malleability, higher cost than lower-karat gold.

18 Karat Gold Engagement Ring

18K gold is made from 75% pure gold and 25% alloy metals such as silver, copper, or zinc. This mix keeps the warm, rich color of gold while adding strength, making it a favorite for designer engagement rings. It offers a high-end look without the extreme softness of 24K gold.

Typical Cost for Mounting: An 18K gold engagement ring setting typically costs between $900 and $1,800. This covers the mounting only and does not include the center stone or additional gems.

With its high gold content, 18K gold holds good value, though not as much as pure 24K, since the added alloys lower its purity.

Pros: Balances luxury with durability, available in yellow or white or rose gold, and more scratch-resistant than 24K gold.

Cons: Costs more than 14K Gold, may cause allergic reactions in people with sensitive skin, and not as highly favored by some jewelers as platinum.

14 Karat Gold Engagement Ring

14K gold is made from 58.3% pure gold mixed with durable alloys. This blend makes it stronger and more affordable than higher-karat gold, while still offering a beautiful finish. Its mix of price, strength, and style has made it the most common choice for engagement rings.

Typical Cost for Mounting: A 14K gold setting usually costs between $600 and $1,200. This price is for the mounting only and doesn’t include the gemstones or diamonds.

While 14K gold is excellent for everyday wear, it holds less resale value than higher-karat gold because of its lower gold content.

Pros: Very durable and perfect for daily wear, comes in yellow and white and rose gold, and more affordable than 18K or 24K gold.

Cons: Lower intrinsic value due to less gold content, has a lesser reputation than 18k and platinum, and may cause allergic reactions in those sensitive to alloys.

Platinum Engagement Ring

Platinum is a rare, naturally white metal known for its strength and non-allergic qualities. It’s one of the most durable metals for engagement ring settings, making it perfect for protecting and highlighting diamonds. Its bright, natural color never fades or needs plating.

Typical Cost for Mounting: A platinum setting typically costs between $1,200 and $2,500. This price is for the mounting only and does not include gemstones or diamonds.

Platinum keeps its value well because of its rarity, though resale prices can vary with the market.

Pros: Extremely strong and resistant to wear, naturally white, forms a beautiful shiny patina after wears of wearing, and great for sensitive skin.

Cons: More expensive upfront than gold and doesn’t come in yellow color.

Titanium Engagement Ring

Titanium is a lightweight, naturally strong metal that resists corrosion and wear. Its sleek, modern appearance makes it a popular choice for simple, minimalist engagement ring designs.

Typical Cost for Mounting: A titanium setting usually costs between $500 and $1,000. This price covers the mounting only and does not include gemstones or diamonds.

While titanium is extremely durable, it has limited resale value because it’s abundant and not as valuable as precious metals like gold or platinum.

Pros: Very strong and scratch-resistant, lightweight and comfortable, and hypoallergenic.

Cons: Difficult to resize, fewer design possibilities due to its hardness, and despite its growing popularity it’s still not widely preferred for engagement rings.

Sterling Silver Engagement Ring

Sterling silver is made from 92.5% pure silver mixed with 7.5% other metals—usually copper—to give it extra strength. It’s affordable, versatile, and often chosen for decorative engagement rings or as a temporary setting.

Typical Cost for Mounting: A sterling silver setting generally costs between $100 and $300. This price is for the mounting only and doesn’t include gemstones or diamonds.

Sterling silver does hold some resale value, since it’s a precious metal, but it’s far less valuable than gold or platinum.

Pros: Budget-friendly and easy to find, can be crafted into detailed, intricate designs, and lightweight and comfortable.

Cons: Tarnishes quickly and needs regular care, softer than other metals, scratches and dents easily, and not durable enough for long-term wear.

White Gold Engagement Ring

White gold is an alloy of yellow gold mixed with white metals such as nickel, palladium, or silver, and is typically plated with rhodium to enhance its bright, reflective finish. Its sleek, contemporary appearance makes it a favorite for engagement rings, especially for accentuating diamonds.

Typical Cost for Mounting: A white gold engagement ring mounting generally costs between $600 and $1,500, excluding gemstones or diamonds.

White gold holds moderate resale value, but its rhodium plating requires regular maintenance to retain its original luster.

Pros: Elegant appearance, more affordable than platinum with a similar look, and durable enough for daily wear.

Cons: Requires replating to maintain its shine and may cause allergic reactions in individuals sensitive to nickel alloys.

Rose Gold Engagement Ring

Rose gold is crafted by combining yellow gold with copper alloys, giving it a warm, pinkish hue that exudes romance and vintage charm. Its unique color makes it a popular choice for engagement rings with intricate or vintage-inspired designs.

Typical Cost for Mounting: A rose gold engagement ring mounting typically costs between $600 and $1,200, not including gemstones or diamonds.

Rose gold holds moderate resale value due to its gold content, though its popularity as a fashion statement contributes to its desirability.

Pros: Romantic hue that suits many skin tones, durable and resistant to tarnishing, and offers a unique and stylish alternative to traditional metals.

Cons: Copper alloy may cause allergies in sensitive individuals, may trend out of style quickly, and less widely available than yellow or white gold.

Insider Tips to Consider When Choosing the Right Metal

Here are our top things to consider when choosing which metal to use for your engagement ring.

• Lifestyle Compatibility: If you lead an active lifestyle or work with your hands, it is important to use a harder metal like platinum or 18k gold.
• Skin Sensitivity: Use a hypoallergenic metal like platinum or titanium if you have sensitive skin.
• Maintenance Requirements: Consider the upkeep of your chosen metal. For example, white gold requires rhodium plating, while sterling silver tarnishes and will need a regular polishing.
• Budget Constraints: Set your budget early. Sterling silver and 14K gold are affordable options, while platinum and 24K gold are quite expensive.
• Long-Term Value: Higher-karat gold, platinum, and silver retain their value better than metals like palladium and titanium for resale or investment potential.
• Gemstone Compatibility: Match your metal to the type of gemstone setting you want.
• Color Preferences: Decide on a color that complements your ring, style and skin tone.
• Future Trends: Stay mindful of metal trends. White gold and rose gold are currently popular, but timeless options like platinum and yellow gold have never gone out of style.
• Wedding Band Pairing: Ensure the engagement ring metal pairs well with your future wedding band to avoid mismatching.

Contact Us

Ready to find your perfect ring?

Contact our expert jewelers at Estate Diamond Jewelry to find the ring that fits your style preferences and budget. We will respond within one business hour.