Estate Diamond Jewelry was founded in 1981. Over the past few years, after we created our website, we began to collect our reviews online. To date, we have over 500 online reviews and counting. Most of our reviews are being collected on Google Reviews, Yelp, Trust Pilot, Wedding Wire, Etsy, and Facebook Business Reviews.

Scroll below to read some of the reviews.

Sherry Holman

I would highly recommend Estate Diamond Jewelry.

I was very hesitant to make such an expensive purchase online. But…there was a vintage diamond and ruby ring that I had seen on their website and I couldn’t get my mind off of it.

I did my research on the company and read reviews so decided to bite the bullet and purchase it. They were so awesome to deal with, they had to size my ring but still got it to me so quick!

Their communication was great, they messaged me on every step. The packaging was even beautiful that it came in. I was scared to open it at first, afraid I would be disappointed, so I waited several hours after it arrived to open it. I kept assuring myself it would be OK because they have a 14 day money back guarantee and wouldn’t even charge for any sizing they had done.

What could be better right? I was so thrilled when I did finally open it, it was even more beautiful than online! I took it to my local jeweler to make sure it was all genuine as claimed. It was authentic and he actually valued it at $5,000. higher than their appraisal value that they had included for insurance purchases.

I have never seen such a beautiful ring and I can’t stop looking at it on my finger. For years I had searched for a unique vintage ruby and diamond ring. I’m so beyond happy with my purchase.

View Source in Google

Anna Kathryn Word

I found Estate Diamond Jewelry online, and when we were in NYC in October, made an appointment to visit and explore their incredible pieces. I fell in love with a unique, one-of-a-kind piece that I’m now lucky enough to own thanks to my husband! The entire experience with Benjamin and his team was delightful from start to finish. I couldn’t be more pleased.

View Source in Google

Akram Faqih

These guys are awesome! I was able to find exactly the right ring for my fiance. They were very flexible and worked with me to find the perfect ring in my budget. Best of all she said yes! Shipping was overnight and arrived in a discrete box as to not ruin the surprise. I highly recommend for anyone who is searching.

View Source in Google

Amalia Ramos

I had a wonderful experience at Estate Diamond Jewelry! Ben and Afshin have an incredible selection of antique jewelry spanning different eras and are lovely people to do business with. I loved the diamond navette ring I bought from them and can’t recommend them enough!

View Source in Google


My husband purchased a magnificent Art Deco Diamond ring for me without having to leave our home in San Diego. had the most gorgeous selection of rings for us to choose from. And at the time of purchase, Afshin said we should come by anytime we are in New York to have a complimentary cleaning and inspection of my ring.

So, two days ago we took him up on his offer and he is just as nice and knowledgeable in person. Not only did he clean my ring, but he showed me, per my request, diamond earrings with European backs. Though we did not purchase any, I made my husband promise that from now on, any purchase of earrings, bracelets, and necklaces for me has to come from this venue. You can’t imagine the beautiful selection they have.

Now the dilemma is, what do I prefer to receive next…the Edwardian style diamond earrings, or the gorgeous Art Deco diamond bracelet or a necklace from the 1930s. They are competitively priced, and are of a better quality than those found in any retail store that I know of.

Source from Trust Pilot

Heather B.

My husband and I highly recommend Estate Diamond Jewelry!  I knew that I wanted an antique ring as my engagement ring –I was initially looking at Edwardian and Art Deco rings online to get ideas.  Estate Diamond Jewelry had great reviews so I called and made us an appointment and let them know what we were interested in.  We ended up finding a truly special, one-of-a-kind ring that took my breath away!  We did go to other antique jewelry stores to browse but the quality was not the same and we saw lots of much lower-quality stones that didn’t have any certifications and they were “guessing” at the grade levels, etc, which made us uncomfortable that we didn’t know what we would be buying.

Estate Diamond Jewelry also has amazing customer service.  I’ve had the ring for 1 year and when I thought the stone had gotten a bit loose, they were happy to have me in to fix it on the spot.  I also reached out needing more info for our insurance company and they got me what I needed the same day!  Based on both the exceptional quality of the jewelry coupled with the top-notch customer service, we would 100% go to Estate Diamond Jewelry if we ever are shopping for another special piece of jewelry.

View Source in Yelp

Victor Tyler

I had a wonderful experience working with Estate Diamond Jewelry to purchase an engagement ring for my now fiancé.

I live on the West Coast but that was no issue as Ben hoped on video chat with me to showcase the ring and provide all necessary details. It was then sent overnight with their 14-day return policy.

Upon arrival, the ring far exceeded my expectations and the overall experience was excellent. I would recommend EDJ to anyone in search of a vintage jewelry. Thanks again!

View Source in Google

Will Cotton

I had such a pleasant experience finding a great ring for my fiance at Estate Diamond Jewelry.

After finding them online, Afshin was very helpful in terms of showing us different options within our price range, and helping us decided on which ring was right for us. We never felt pressured, or that our time wasn’t important to him, and he showed us many so many great options before we decided on the perfect one.

Afshin had such good taste and understood what we liked about some rings more than others. The Payment couldn’t have been easier, and they were able to resize the ring by the next day.

I would highly recommend them to anyone looking for estate or antique jewelry!

View Source in Google


Can’t recommend these folks highly enough, and I couldn’t love my engagement ring more. They’re patient, helpful and have a great selection. Plus it was within my fiance’s budget – win/win!

View Source in Google

Melissa Ortiz

Highly recommend. My fiancé got me my gorgeous engagement ring from this store and I couldn’t be happier.

They have one of a kind pieces, you’ll never have to worry about someone else with the same ring! I get so many compliments on my engagement ring, on how unique it is.

Customer service is great, very friendly staff and super fast service if you need repairs, cleaning, etc.

View Source in Google

Julie Kramer

My partner’s and my wedding rings had been missing and believed stolen for several months when I finally began looking for a new ring online. I was devastated by the loss and not even cheered by the prospect of a lovely new ring.

However, I consistently found myself drawn to Estate Diamond Jewelry’s website and I slowly started to warm up to the idea of choosing something that felt like me now, since my rings were nearly 20 years old.

We were going to be in NYC, so off we went to Estate Diamond Jewelry where we were warmly welcomed by Benjamin. I could write volumes about the overall experience during the next three days of deciding on my ring, which was quite a process! His collection has been carefully curated and is truly impressive. Suffice it to say that it was one of the most enjoyable purchasing experiences of our lives, which is high praise considering the grief that we were feeling over our missing rings.

My stunning new ring was shipped to me in Colorado and four days after it arrived, our original wedding rings were found and returned to us. Needless to relate, I’m keeping my beautiful diamond cluster ring from Estate Diamond Jewelers!
Submitted via Review Collection Portal

Megan Carley

We bought my engagement ring from Estate Diamond Jewelry about two years ago- it was a great process and the staff was incredibly nice and helpful. I never felt rushed or pressured and they were very knowledgeable about the history of the rings, the styles etc.

Recently, one of the prongs loosened and I needed it fixed. The process couldn’t have been easier. They were able to accommodate my schedule, fix it quickly, and even had it cleaned and looking like new for me. It’s been a great experience and I highly recommend them.

View Source in Google

Clifton Rogers

Great communication, I trust them and they showed mutual trust. I got a ring from them, I ordered the wrong size, they sent a return label, made a new ring and sent it out earlier than I expected.

It’s perfect & my fiancé loves it. I highly recommend estate diamond jewelry and will be using them for all my future jewelry investments. Thanks!

View Source in Google

Alexandra Okay

When my fiancé started ring shopping he immediately went to Estate Diamond Jewelry for my engagement ring because he’d heard amazing things about them.

Let me just say how happy I am that he did!

He worked directly with Ben who was absolutely unbelievable. He guided my fiancé every step of the way, constantly making sure everything was perfect, and even checked in post-proposal to make sure the ring fit and there were no problems.

We had an amazing experience dealing with them and would highly recommend Estate Diamond Jewelry to anyone who wants nothing short of an incredible and seamless experience.

View Source in Google

Erin C

I can’t tell you how amazing these two are. Not only did they get back to me ASAP, I was able to find the ring of my dreams! Thank you and highly recommend them!

Submitted via Review Collection Portal

Heather B.

I can’t stress enough how much I enjoyed my experience with Estate Diamond Jewelry.

My girlfriend and I had a fun afternoon of sorts where after brunch we met with several jewelers to look at potential rings for if I were to pop the question.

Estate Diamond was easily the best.  In addition to a very professional but relaxing meeting, their ring selection was far superior to others in the area.  My girlfriend fell in love with one in particular and we got the info.  When it was time to propose I was able to buy it on the site and Afshin, who I had met months prior, knew who I was.

We had great communication and Afshin was very accommodating and understanding.  This speaks volumes in regards to their care for detail and speaking of, they show the same care with their rings.  I popped the question and my fiancee can not stop gushing over the rings.

Absolutely 5 star experience.

View Source in Yelp

Andrea Pugliese

I had been casually browsing engagement rings at the encouragement of boyfriend. I had figured out that I wanted an antique ring, and hoped we could find one with sapphires that was unlike I had seen before, especially in its delicacy.

Then I came across Estate Diamond Jewelry and fell in love with their Boston Ring. It fit all of our criteria. I reached out to Benjamin to book an appointment at their showroom. They were extremely accommodating to our schedules, and stayed beyond their hours so we could come in.

As soon as I tried on the ring we both knew it was the one. To be safe, we tried on many other options, each of which was as beautiful, but they only solidified that we had found our ring. The entire process was so easy and Benjamin removed any of our anxieties. If you want a beautiful ring with history and of the highest quality, from a small business of kind and knowledgeable people, look no further.

And if you’re not as lucky as we are to live in New York City, they have their amazing home-viewing program for your convenience.

Submitted to Google Reviews

Anastasia Morozova

I could not recommend Estate Diamond Jewelry more! They are a joy to work with – fair, courteous, responsive, warm, and – of course – they have the most gorgeous selection of jewelry.

My now-fiance and I looked at many potential engagement rings in so many places, tried on probably dozens of rings, and nothing was quite right. When we found Estate Diamond Jewelry, we had the best experience; they were quick to reply to us, easy to make appointments with, and very welcoming when we tried on several beautiful options before finding my perfect ring.

Months later, I can’t stop admiring it, and constantly get compliments on how unique and perfect for me it is – and I agree!

Of course, we’re working with them again for our wedding bands, and will no doubt return to them many times in the future for other beautiful pieces. Cannot thank them and recommend them enough!

View Source in Google

Cam Holt

Truly an amazing ring that I received! My fiancé is blown away by the quality & look. Excellent customer service as well!

View Source in Google


I can’t stress enough how much I enjoyed my experience with Estate Diamond Jewelry. My girlfriend and I had a fun afternoon of sorts where after brunch we met with several jewelers to look at potential rings for if I were to pop the question.

Estate Diamond was easily the best.

In addition to a very professional but relaxing meeting, their ring selection was far superior to others in the area. My girlfriend fell in love with one in particular and we got the info.

When it was time to propose I was able to buy it on the site and Afshin, who I had met months prior, knew who I was. We had great communication and Afshin was very accommodating and understanding. This speaks volumes in regards to their care for detail and speaking of, they show the same care with their rings. I popped the question and my fiancee can not stop gushing over the rings.

Absolutely 5 star experience.

View Source in Google

Rachel Militana

I highly recommend Estate Diamond Jewelry for their selection of antique rings and service.

I wanted an antique ring when my husband proposed 8 years ago, but we were nervous to purchase anything online and couldn’t find a ring we liked locally. I lost my Tiffany and Co ring we had ended up purchasing at the gym earlier this year and was devastated! I had been looking for my original “dream” antique ring the past few months and finally found a very unique 1900s Edwardian ring on their website.

I spoke with Afshin and he held it while I thought about it. I was nervous to buy something I found online, but Afshin answered all my questions, was never pushy, and assured me if I didn’t like it I could always return it. Shipping was a breeze and once I received it, it exceeded my expectations and the photos. It’s a stunning ring and the packaging was so professional.

I feel like the sting of losing my original engagement ring has totally gone away – I have the ring I always dreamed of now for a fabulous price and it was a wonderful experience doing business with EDJ.

View Source in Google

Norah Geraghty

I would highly recommend Estate Diamond Jewelry to anyone who is looking for a gorgeous, vintage, one of a kind ring. I am thrilled with mine. Afshin made the selection experience fun and interesting – I will definitely recommend them to my family and I will be back!

Submitted via Review Collection Portal

Amy Kissling

I’m torn over which is more beautiful – my new ring or the incredible experience I had buying from Estate Diamond Jewelry.

All along the process, which I did online, the great staff of EDJ kept me informed by email and phone. And my ring was re-sized and on my finger 2 days after I put it in my cart.

I have no doubt that my next jewelry purchase will be from EDJ.

Submitted via Review Collection Portal

Erin Duggan

Such a GREAT place!

My fiance bought my engagement ring from them. The ring is absolutely gorgeous and such a high quality. The diamond and design are both breath taking.

We went back to have my ring resized around the holidays, and they were so kind and accommodating. I could not have asked for a better ring or experience. Definitely recommend them!

View Source in Google

Bobby Keen

Could not be more pleased with the ring and service we received. We were a little hesitant to buy an expensive ring via the Internet-not in person viewing.

However, working with the professional staff at Estate Diamond Jewelry put us at ease. The 14 day money back guarantee and GIA Certification made us willing to move forward with the purchase.

The ring was exactly as pictured and described in the GIA report. We got the ring sized and received it in 2 days – that is amazing!

We will buy again with confidence. They are a class operation!

View Source in Google

Janet and Rene’

Handwritten testimonial and review:

Submitted via Review Collection Portal

Jack Lowdon

Life happens. After 30 years of marriage, my wife’s engagement ring went missing, and I wanted to replace it with a unique estate piece. I was at first hesitant to purchase fine jewelry on the Internet, but, based on this experience, you can feel completely confident dealing with EDJ.

We found a breathtaking antique diamond ring, Afshin assisted us in a most pleasant and professional manner, and we are thrilled with our purchase.

Hopefully, my wife will treasure this ring for another 30 years…thank you, Afshin and EDJ.

Submitted via Review Collection Portal

Jeff Consalvo

Very pleased with the Service Ben and the Estate Diamond Jewelry Team Provided. The ring is gorgeous and exactly as described and photos portrayed.

Box and packing along with Cert are perfect.

Thanks again for being patient with me.

Submitted via Review Collection Portal

Doug & Kelly Esposito

Afshin and Ben were exceptional to work with. They answered our questions over telephone calls and emails, as well as sent a video of the ring on a colleague’s hand. What I truly appreciated was that they helped me with a creative story that made it possible for me to surprise my bride with the ring.  After the surprise engagement and wedding – all in the same day, we needed the ring resized. We shipped it back to their office and they returned it to us within 24 hours. The ring is absolutely stunning and perfect!  We can’t say enough about how wonderful Estate Diamond Jewelry is and highly recommend them for any jewelry purchases!

Submitted via Review Collection Portal

More Reviews Coming Soon

Please Note: More reviews will be uploaded to this page soon! Stay tuned!


I strongly recommend Estate Diamond Jewelry.  The atmosphere was very relaxed and educational with no sales pressure.  This was my first time buying an estate ring and in my opinion it is very different from buying a traditional ring from a large jeweler.  It is much more personal, much more specific, and much more rewarding as there is a sense of history.

Working with Afshin and Ben was great.  They explained the details and context of jewelry from the particular period for each piece.  Overall, we are very pleased with an amazing ring, that is as unique and beautiful as our relationship.


Thank you for everything! She loves the ring.

The picture of the proposal is attached.



Thank you again for allowing me to purchase such a beautiful vintage engagement ring and I look forward to doing business with you again in the future.


It’s been 10 years since my last purchase, a Asscher cut diamond and sapphire ring I adore, and I still come back to your site to browse the incredible selections. I look forward to doing business with you again!

Congrats on the site update. It is very well done!

Jason wrote:

I purchased our engagement ring a few months ago and absolutely love it! EDJ was very easy to work with and answered all my questions quickly and accurately. I was a little worried about buying online and if the ring would match my expectations but it arrived and was exactly as described.

Jennifer Choiniere wrote:

I cannot recommend M. Khordipour enough. My husband bought my engagement ring over 6 years ago, and they still treat us like we are their number one customer. What simply amazes me is that every time I have had to go in for re-sizing or cleaning etc, they take one look at the ring and remember us. Sarah is absolutely great and has been nothing but wonderful. I wish I knew more people in need of their services so I could point them in the right direction!! A big thanks to everyone there! Jen & Ezra

Annie L. wrote:

Hi, I recently received a ring from my fiance Jacob for our engagement. It is stunning and you did an amazing job creating the band. Because the band is so intricate, I was wondering about how to properly care for the ring and clean it. The link to the band I received is below, please let me know your thoughts. Again, the ring is more beautiful then I could have ever imagined. Thank you so much!

Thank you,

Gina wrote:

Dear Sarah and Afshin:  Thank you so much for finding me the most wonderful stone!  It was great working with you and knowing that I was in such honest, reputable hands.  Having been into your shop is a great experience, but I must say that you have one of the few websites that shows off your jewelry beautifully.  You can feel assured that you are getting accurate information even though you are not in the shop.  You work very hard to educate and please your customer, and I appreciated it greatly since much of the stone selection and design  was done over the phone.

Once again, many thanks!

Debbie Unsworth wrote:

My earrings arrived this am and the lever-backs are exactly as I requested.  The earrings are set lower so I have a lot more dangle.  I just wanted to thank you again.  Your customer service is excellent.  See you at the next Miami show.


Vanessa Johnson wrote:

Just wanted to write and tell you how pleased I am with the ring!! It’s beautiful and I could not be happier with my customer service experience from beginning to end. The team was so responsive and patient while I asked a million questions. I had such a hard time finding THE perfect ring…with a true vintage look. It is hard to replicate the quality and intricate detail and yet somehow you have managed to do that and at very good prices. The craftsmanship is really unbelievable. I get no less than 10 compliments a day, from complete strangers. I do find myself talking with my hands as much as possible as well (haha) and I admire the ring probably 1000x a day. Thank you very much!!! This will be an heirloom to pass to my daughter or son one day…something to remain in the family for 100’s of years to come. Love it. Best,

Vanessa Johnson (Chicago)

Mary Winston wrote:

Dear Afshin,
I received the ring yesterday, via Federal Express.  Thank you so much!!!  It is *just beautiful*!!!  I am so happy with it!  Please keep me updated on anything that you think I might like.  Maybe I’ll make it to New York to visit some time!  Take care, and stay warm!  🙂

Very truly yours,


Nina Goldberg wrote:

I just wanted to thank you so much for my beautiful ring! It is much more beautiful that the picture on the web site and than I had imagined it to be! Bruce Stillman is now my fiance thanks to you! I appreciate all of your assistance and patience with ac couple who had a specific budget to work with in. Thank you…. you have made a customer for life!

Lauren Gruender wrote:

Hello,I would to comment how lovely your website is, even more so the engagement rings.
I found the rings to be exquisite and well refined.


Jennifer wrote:

Dear Sarah,
I just got back from picking up my ring. I am amazed by the workmanship. The ring itself is much more dainty then I had originally thought it would be but it just adds to the beauty. I don’t think I will be able to tell you how happy and pleased I am with my ring. I just keep staring at it, it’s beautiful.

Thank you for making my dream ring a reality. You made the process very easy for me and and I felt comfortable with placing my order over the phone. While it was a long two weeks the ring was definitely worth the wait.

You have a repeat customer in me and I hope to place another order with you again in the near future. I can’t wait to show all of my friends my new ring.

I just don’t know what to say except that I LOVE my ring.

Thank you so much.

P.S. Feel free to post this on your website if you wish.

Submit a Review

Have you purchased a product from us? We love receiving feedback from our customers! Please click here and leave us your review.