Everything You Need To Know About Diamond Clarity December 18, 2017 – Posted in: Jewelry Blog
Clarity is one of the 4Cs of diamond classification. It is a measure of the extent to which a diamond contains internal (inclusions) or surface (blemishes) flaws. Each inclusion or blemish will detract from the brilliance of a polished diamond. The flaw will interfere with the refraction of light as it travels through the diamond.
- Diamond Clarity Chart
- What Causes Blemishes?
- How to Find Inclusions?
- Types of Flaws
- The Scale of Diamond Clarity
- Enhancing Diamond Clarity
- Which Clarity to Buy?
Diamond Clarity Chart
There are many diamond Clarity Charts that try and break down the blemishes in diamonds and their grades. Unfortunately, most of them are only useful for experts. We created two charts to help you understand diamond clarity. The first one shows the diamonds in their order (ranking from SI2 – F Clarity) as they are. The second chart shows the visible inclusions on the diamond.
Here is the second chart. We’ve circled the visible inclusions. Please note that the IF Clarity and F Clarity don’t have any visible inclusions.
What Causes Inclusions and Blemishes?
Diamonds will take over a period of between 1 and 3 billion years to form. Despite their unique structure and composition, it is inevitable that the stones acquire flaws and imperfections along the way. The diamond cutter will take great effort to work around these flaws. A long process, usually complicated by fault lines, dictates where the cut will be made.
Flawless diamonds aren’t common and become extremely rare once sizes get above 2 carats. Most rough stones large enough from which to produce larger diamonds rarely are free of inclusions.
How to Find Inclusions?
Diamonds are graded using a 10x Loupe, a special magnifying lens used by jewelers and other industries to get a close-up view of things that might not be seen with the naked eye.
Blemishes, being surface issues, are usually easier to see than inclusions, and occasionally may be located using the naked eye. Inclusions, on the other hand, can’t. If a very large inclusion can be seen without a loupe, the diamond is poor quality. Poor quality diamonds will usually be used for industrial cutting types of equipment.
One exception is with black diamonds. Black diamonds aren’t actually black. They are so included that light cannot escape, giving the appearance of the diamond being black. Black diamonds, whilst rare, are not generally sought after. They aren’t usually used unless explicitly specified for a certain design of a ring or jewelry piece.
If inclusions or blemishes cannot be avoided in the finished stone, the stone will have been polished in a special way. Usually, the cutter will try and position the inclusion as close to the girdle as possible. Inclusions beside the girdle are harder to see and have less effect on the brilliance of the diamond.
Types of Flaws
Diamond flaws can occur in several different forms. Some are internal, which class as inclusions and others are surface faults – often man-made – and are known as blemishes.
Fully understanding inclusions is beyond the scope of this article, but in this section we will try to familiarize you with the basic inclusions and how to identify them.
Pinpoint and Needle
Pinpoint is when a minute second mineral has become trapped within the diamond as it forms. Needles are similar, but are thought to have been stretched as the diamond crystal grows in size. In isolation, pinpoint and needle don;t usually detract from the overall appearance of the diamond.
A cloud inclusion is actually a tightly grouped collection of pinpoint or needle inclusions. If sufficient in number and location, a cloud can cause the loss of sparkle in the diamond. Cloud inclusions are amongst the most common of all inclusion types.
Wisps are is caused by pauses in the crystal growth. Occasionally, a diamond crystal will stop growing due to changes in external conditions. Eventually, things will change again, and the diamond will recommence growing. This causes streaking or cloudiness around the stop/start point, and is actually a collection of various types of inclusion.
Similar to a pinpoint flaw, knots are when the rogue crystal is at the surface of the polished diamond, and cannot be eliminated.
Ideally, diamond crystals will grow at a fairly constant rate. This gives us the best clarity in rough stones. Graining occurs when the growth rate is irregular. Extra stresses in the crystal are caused by sudden spurts or slowing of the growing process. It manifests itself in streaking within the diamond.
Occasionally, a diamond crystal will contain natural indents. Most can be removed with careful cutting and polishing, but some remain. They are usually around the girdle, thereby limiting the detrimental effect on the cut diamond.
A feather is a cavity or crack within the diamond crystal. Depending on the location, they can seriously affect durability of the stone, and are a weak spot within the rough crystal. Feather inclusions are commonly responsible for chips in polished diamonds.
The vast majority of diamond surface blemishes are the result of poor polishing. These are commonly caused by inconsistent pressure when polishing, or using too much heat. The result is a dulled appearance on one or more facets.
Bearding occurs around the girdle of a diamond if the bruting, or cutting, part of the process is not of sufficient quality. It produces hair-like wisps on the edges of the girdle, hence the name.
Another result of insufficient polishing skills, lizard skin is a rippled effect on the surface of the polished diamond.
Abrasion is minute nicks along facet edges. It gives the edges a dull, often fuzzy appearance.
Why Some Inclusions Are Better Than Others
Ideally, all diamonds would be flawless, but that is not the case. Far from it, in fact. Almost all diamonds have some flaw or other, whether an inclusion or surface blemish. As polishing techniques have improved, we now see fewer blemishes as a result of the manufacturing process. Some natural surface flaws do occur, but skilled polishers can usually avoid them. Internal flaws, though occur in almost all diamonds.
If you had to choose a diamond flaw to have, pinpoint is about the “best”. Single pinpoints don’t generally affect the clarity of the diamond significantly. They are certainly not visible without 10x magnification. As a result, diamonds with only one or two pinpoint inclusions and no others are very expensive and rare.
Cloud inclusions are actually very common. because of this, a lot of diamonds have cloud flaws. Most are fairly minor issues, however, and will not be obvious. The rest will depend entirely on location and size. During the grading process, diamonds are viewed from the crown down. If flaws are not visible from this angle, they will often not affect the grade too much.
Diamond Clarity Grades
The clarity of a diamond can make a big difference to its value. The higher the grade, in short, the rarer the diamond. This is especially true with diamonds over 2ct in size. To differentiate between the various levels of clarity, we use a scale from the Gemological Institute of America (GIA). They range from Flawless to Included, with six main grades. Some grades have different levels, meaning we have eleven grades in all.
As the name suggests, a flawless diamond has no internal or surface flaws under 10x magnification. Such diamonds are so rare that few dealers have them available to buy. Many only appear for sale at specialist auction houses.
Internally Flawless (IF)
With IF diamonds, only surface blemishes are present. These are only visible, again, under 10x magnification. IF will usually be the best grade available through general retailers but, even then, they are not commonly seen.
Very Very Slightly Included (VVS)
VVS has two sub-grades – VVS1 and VVS2. Inclusions in VVS diamonds are difficult for even a skilled grader to see under magnification. Although still quite rare, VVS diamonds are much more easily available than IF diamonds.
Very Slightly Included (VS)
Inclusions in VS diamonds are usually easy to spot for a skilled grader under magnification. The grade is broken down into VS1 Clarity and VS2 clarity. It is the VS grade which makes up the majority of diamonds bought today.
Slightly Included (SI)
By the time we get to SI diamonds, flaws are easy to spot under magnification. Occasionally, some SI2 diamonds may also have inclusions visible to the naked eye. Many dealers will not stock SI diamonds, especially SI2, as they are usually quite low value unless exceptionally large.
Click here to learn about “SI3 Clarity”.
Inclusions in any of the 3 I grade diamonds are obvious under magnification. They are also often easily visible without. Many I3 diamonds end up in cheap jewelry or even in industrial applications, rather than in engagement rings. Brilliance is greatly affected and demand is generally low for I graded diamonds.
Which Clarity To Choose
Budget will be a big factor when purchasing any diamond. If money is less of a consideration for you, then by all means go for the best you can get, with VVS clarity an excellent choice. If, though, your bank account is not bottomless, then VS clarity diamonds are a terrific compromise of grade and price. VS diamonds do have flaws, but they are rarely visible with the naked eye. As nobody you show your engagement ring to will be carrying a jeweler’s magnification loupe, unless they are a jeweler, the diamond will appear all but perfect.
Perhaps surprisingly, a VS2 diamond may be as little as a quarter of the price of an IF or even VVS1 diamond. This makes them a very attractive option. Available numbers of VS diamonds are also much higher than VVS or IF stones. This increases your choice of size and cut.
How to Determine Diamond Clarity?
The clarity of a polished diamond is graded on a scale ranging from Flawless (FL) to Included Grade 3 (I3). Flawless diamonds have no visible inclusions or blemishes. Only around 0.02% of all the diamonds produced are flawless. Such a grading plays a large part in the valuation of a diamond. Although Internally Flawless (IF) diamonds have no inclusions, they will have blemishes that can be seen at 10x magnification.
Slightly Included Grade 1 (SI1) is the 7th level of clarity on the scale and is considered the final grade at which inclusions cannot be seen with the naked eye. The next level (SI2) will have inclusions that are visible without magnification. They will also require further, magnified, inspection to determining the extent of the inclusions effect on the overall clarity.
The Scale of Diamond Clarity
The full scale of clarity grading is as follows:
SI2 usually visible but require closer inspection to determine the extent to which they affect the grade.
VS2 indicates inclusions may be detectable by the naked eye, under ideal viewing conditions.
SI1 and SI2 feature slight inclusions. SI1 Clarity is the lowest grade at which inclusions are invisible to the naked eye.
|FL||Flawless – No inclusions or blemishes detectable under 10x magnification.|
|IF||Internally Flawless – No inclusions detectable under 10x magnification. Blemishes detectable under 10x magnification.|
|VVS1 and VVS2||Very Very Slightly Included – Inclusions are difficult to detect under 10x magnification, but are present. VVS1 inclusions are detectable from the pavilion, and VVS2 from the crown.|
|VS1 and VS2||Very Slightly Included – Inclusions clearly visible under 10x magnification, but usually classed as a minor.|
|I1, I2, and I3||Included – The lowest grade on the scale, and may have quite pronounced exclusions clearly visible to the naked eye.|
Enhancing The Clarity Of A Diamond
We like to think of all diamonds as being truly natural. There are techniques however that can adjust the appearance of polished stones. One example is laser modification. Advanced lasers will drill a very fine hole from the surface to the inclusion. They then insert acid into the hole in order to bleach the inclusions and make it more difficult to detect.
The GIA won’t certify diamonds with fracture-fillings. Fracture-filled diamonds aren’t true and are, therefore, unnatural.
Make sure that you check your certificate to determine that your diamond is truly natural.
Where Cut and Color Fit In
Cur and color of a diamond are probably more important than either clarity or carat weight. Even a flawless, colorless diamond will likely look terrible if the cut quality is poor. Similarly, almost all diamonds have color. Because of this, diamond size becomes a potential issue as similar color levels look different in large and small diamonds. Unless you are planning to use a yellow gold setting, try and get the faintest color diamond you can. Otherwise, setting in platinum or white gold can expose even the faintest hint of yellow in the diamond.
This is true regardless of clarity or weight. Again, though, use your eyes to guide you. Many non-colorless diamonds will actually look colorless unless side by side with a true D (colorless) color diamond. Let what you see in the diamond be the reason for your choice, rather than what it says on the grading certificate.
Which Clarity To Buy?
There is something very special about owning a flawless diamond. They are very rare and hard to come by. There is, however, a catch. They come with a significant price premium attached.
If you want an investment diamond, then IF and F clarity may be a good idea. If you don’t want to spend a lot of amount of money, you may need to settle for VVS1 and lower.
Although VVS2 and VVS1 are much more expensive than VS1 and VS2, most experts cannot even tell them apart.
If you want a diamond that shows no visible inclusions and is affordable our recommendation would be to focus on VS1 and VS2. If you don’t a few small visible inclusions you can even drop to SI1. We strongly recommend not going less than SI1 unless you have no choice.
If you can live with the knowledge that your diamond is less than perfect, you can compromise without any perceived loss in quality. Unless an expert is examining your diamond, most average quality diamonds will not show any inclusions.
Which Matters Most, Clarity or Carat Weight?
It’s a good question, and very difficult to answer. In practice, the smaller diamond, the less particular about clarity you need to be. Conversely, the larger the diamond, the less flaws it needs to have. If you choose a large, low-clarity diamond, the lack of brilliance and sparkle can be noticeable.
It’s a vague answer, admittedly, but there is a pretty good way of applying the theory. With diamonds, although we talk about grades a lot, they are not the be all and end all. Instead of worrying too much about the clarity grade, look for diamonds that are eye-clean. By this, we mean diamonds in which inclusions cannot be seen without magnification. They may well be present, but if you can’t see them, why should it matter? This opens up options for you to look at larger diamonds than you might otherwise do.
We wouldn’t recommend going beyond VS2, especially at 2ct or above, but the choice is yours. With a little craft and guile, you can get so much more for your money that it will surprise you.
Clarity is but one element which influences both the appearance and value of a diamond. With clarity, an expert eye is most important when assessing whether a particular diamond is right for you.
A reputable jeweler will always be willing to explain why a diamond has achieved a particular grade. Don’t be afraid to ask for help and advice.