Skip to navigation
Skip to main content
1 (212) 265 3868
Schedule Appointment
Cart
0
items
0
Wishlist
Free Overnight Shipping · 45+ Years of Expertise · 14-Day Returns · 750+ Reviews
Skip Navigation
Vintage Engagement Rings
Estate Jewelry
Close
Vintage Jewelry
Vintage Engagement Rings
Cocktail Rings
Wedding Bands
Vintage Earrings
Vintage Necklaces
Colored Diamonds
Luxury Designer Jewelry
Vintage Men’s Jewelry
Vintage Braclets
All Vintage Jewelry
Shop Rings
Close
Shop by Gemstones
Diamond Rings
Sapphire Rings
Aquamarine Rings
Ruby Rings
Amethyst Rings
Emerald Rings
Kunzite Rings
Fancy Diamond Rings
Yellow Diamond Rings
Champagne Diamond Rings
Shop by Diamond Cut
Old European Cut Rings
Cushion Cut Rings
Asscher Cut Rings
Emerald Cut Rings
Rose Cut Rings
Oval Cut Rings
Old Mine Cut Rings
Shop by Era
Georgian Era Rings
–
Circa 1714 – 1837
Victorian Era Rings
–
Circa 1837 – 1901
Edwardian Era Rings
–
Circa 1901 – 1910
Art Deco Era Rings
–
Circa 1920 – 1940
Retro Era Rings
–
Circa 1940 – 1950
Mid-Century Rings
–
Circa 1950 – 1970
Shop by Carat Weight
1 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
2 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
3 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
4 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
5 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
6 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
Rare Collections
Close
Kashmir Sapphires
No-Oil Colombian Emeralds
Burma Rubies
Natural Saltwater Pearls
Cartier Jewelry
Van Cleef & Arpels Jewelry
Tiffany & Co. Jewelry
About Us
Blog
Resources
Close
Sell Your Jewelry
Ring Sizing Kit
Jewelry Education
Ring Budget Calculator
Ask Jewelry Expert
Monthly Birthstones
Sold Jewelry
Contact Us
Close
Search
More results...
Menu
0
Jewelry Gifts Under $5000
Showing 271–300 of 427 results
Filters
Show sidebar
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Georgian Pearl, Diamond and Ruby Tulare Ring, Circa 1810
$
3,800
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
GIA 0.82ct Fancy Yellow-Brown Diamond Merrillan Ring
$
5,000
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
GIA 1.05ct No Heat Ruby and Diamond Cluster Manter Ring
$
4,800
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
GIA 1.16ct Ruby and Diamond Halo Lanesboro Pendant
$
4,000
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
GIA 1.62ct Pear Shaped Sapphire and Diamond Fernbank Ring
$
3,800
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Half Eternity French Cut Sapphire Ouray Band 2.6mm
$
2,300
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Italian Buccellati Blossom Sapphire Necklace
$
4,000
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Landscape Charm Necklace. Circa 1920
$
3,700
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Marquise Cut Aquamarine and Sapphire Dongola Ring
$
3,500
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Moonstone and Sapphire Stud Correll Earrings
$
3,800
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Old European Cut Diamond Elongated Platinum Barclay Ring
$
3,500
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Old European Cut Diamond Stud Willard Earrings
$
3,000
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Old European Cut Three-Stone Diamond Filigree Foster Ring
$
2,250
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Onyx and 18k Yellow Gold Talanga Ring
$
900
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Opal & Halo of Diamonds Yellow Gold Monclova Earrings
$
600
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Opal and Sapphire Halo Stud Turton Earrings
$
3,500
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Oval Amethyst and Diamond Halo Salem Earrings
$
1,800
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Oval Cut Opal and Diamond Arbala Necklace
$
750
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Oval Cut Sapphire and Diamond Vinson Ring
$
950
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Oval Cut White Gold Opal Solana Ring
$
850
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Oval Opal and Diamond Yellow Gold Durant Ring
$
700
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Oval Opal Yellow Gold Stud Tira Earrings
$
500
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Palermo Amethyst Ring
$
950
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Pear-Shape Diamond and Sapphire Marceline Pendant
$
4,300
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Platinum 1.03ct Oval Emerald and Sapphire Halo Scarab Ring
$
4,200
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Platinum 1×1 Sapphire and Diamond Eternity Maher Band. 2mm
$
1,900
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Platinum 2×1 Emerald and Diamond Half Eternity Bell Grove Band 2.60mm
$
2,200
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Platinum 2×1 Ruby and Diamond Half Eternity Lakeview Band. 2.6mm
$
1,400
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Platinum 3×3 Diamond and Emerald Half Eternity Hamden Band. 2.6mm
$
1,850
Add to cart
Add to wishlist
Platinum 3×3 Ruby and Diamond Wedding Kenville Band. 2.7mm
$
1,750
Close
Search
More results...
Skip Navigation
Vintage Engagement Rings
Estate Jewelry
Close
Vintage Jewelry
Vintage Engagement Rings
Cocktail Rings
Wedding Bands
Vintage Earrings
Vintage Necklaces
Colored Diamonds
Luxury Designer Jewelry
Vintage Men’s Jewelry
Vintage Braclets
All Vintage Jewelry
Shop Rings
Close
Shop by Gemstones
Diamond Rings
Sapphire Rings
Aquamarine Rings
Ruby Rings
Amethyst Rings
Emerald Rings
Kunzite Rings
Fancy Diamond Rings
Yellow Diamond Rings
Champagne Diamond Rings
Shop by Diamond Cut
Old European Cut Rings
Cushion Cut Rings
Asscher Cut Rings
Emerald Cut Rings
Rose Cut Rings
Oval Cut Rings
Old Mine Cut Rings
Shop by Era
Georgian Era Rings
–
Circa 1714 – 1837
Victorian Era Rings
–
Circa 1837 – 1901
Edwardian Era Rings
–
Circa 1901 – 1910
Art Deco Era Rings
–
Circa 1920 – 1940
Retro Era Rings
–
Circa 1940 – 1950
Mid-Century Rings
–
Circa 1950 – 1970
Shop by Carat Weight
1 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
2 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
3 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
4 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
5 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
6 Carat Rings
–
Loose Diamonds and Rings
Rare Collections
Close
Kashmir Sapphires
No-Oil Colombian Emeralds
Burma Rubies
Natural Saltwater Pearls
Cartier Jewelry
Van Cleef & Arpels Jewelry
Tiffany & Co. Jewelry
About Us
Blog
Resources
Close
Sell Your Jewelry
Ring Sizing Kit
Jewelry Education
Ring Budget Calculator
Ask Jewelry Expert
Monthly Birthstones
Sold Jewelry
Contact Us
Close
Search
More results...