Top 30 Vintage Engagement Rings Etsy

September 13, 2023 – Posted in: Jewelry Blog

Etsy is among the most popular handmade and vintage item marketplaces. This includes jewelry, even fine antique and vintage jewelry. It’s no wonder why so many people visit Etsy shops when looking for the perfect engagement ring. However, such a wide range of products from all over the world may be very overwhelming so as a result, we’ve created this top 30 list of vintage engagement rings on Etsy. 

In this list, we’ve gathered the best vintage engagement rings on Etsy. From feminine Victorian-era designs to angular and minimalistic retro-era styles, we’ve got a ring for everyone – read on to find yours. 

1. Edwardian Era Three-Stone Diamond Ring

Platinum And White Gold Ring With Three Diamonds

Price: $3,000

This French Edwardian-era vintage ring has a classical style, yet also possesses a timeless beauty. This platinum on 18k white gold ring hosts three stones; a cushion-cut center diamond of J color, and an old mine-cut diamond on each side. The total weight of the three stones is approximately 0.95 carats, with the flanking stones each accounting for 0.25 carats.

This ring is a fantastic representative of what rings on Etsy have to offer, but it’s also just the beginning.

2.  Gold Vintage Leaf Motif Ring

Estate Diamond Jewelry Sydney Gold Diamond Engagement Ring

Price: $8,000

This charming and luxurious ring will surely be a perfect fit for the most feminine brides. The 1.16-carat antique center diamond boasts J color and VS2 quality and is enhanced by the delicate embellishments this ring has to offer.

Perhaps the most notable piece of the design is the leaf motif shoulders; each of which presents three diamond-adorned leaves. What’s more, the prongs not only enhance the center stone’s visibility, but also play well into the leaf theme of the ring. Finally, the triple-wire shank on this 18k gold ring boosts this ring’s elegant and delicate style.

3. Fancy Yellow Diamond Ring 

Yellow Diamond Ring With Diamond Halo From Etsy

Price: $11,500

If you prefer diamonds but fancy a dash of color, then this unique ring will be a perfect choice.

The stylish swirling starburst design supports the rare sunny-yellow, 1.39-carat center diamond rather well. A 0.92-carat halo of white marquise diamonds surrounds the elevated oval-cut treasure in the center. Finally, the shoulders and shank of this 18k white gold ring are minimal, proving to be an excellent subtle complement to the unique design of this special ring.

4. Delicate Sapphire Halo Diamond Ring

Delicate Asscher Cut Diamond Ring With Sapphire Halo

Price: $5,000

This charming ring features a mix of blue sapphires and white diamonds, thus producing a stunning contrast. The Asscher-cut center stone weighs approximately 0.50 carats and is J color and VS1 clarity. Although the shank is plain, several small diamonds adorn the shoulders. The fine milgrain bordering the shoulders and the halo provide some sparkling emphasis, while the openwork gallery completes the look.

5. Baguette Diamond Ring With 6 Diamond Accents

Gold Ring With Center Diamond And Six Accent Diamonds

Price: $6,500

If you’re looking for the most impressive mix of elegance and luxury, then search no further than this Edwardian gold ring. The 0.95-carat old mine-cut center diamond is GIA-certified as J color and SI1 clarity. Meanwhile, three diamonds line each of the shoulders. Finally, the ring was handcrafted in 18k yellow gold circa 1900.

For those who want something spectacular yet understated, this ring is a slam dunk.

6. Asscher Cut Diamond Ring

Price: $2,430

Handcrafted in platinum circa 1950, this vintage ring features a subtle and dainty design featuring an old European-cut center diamond and a tapered baguette diamond on each shoulder.

The total weight of the diamonds is approximately 0.62 carats, of which the center diamond accounts for 0.57 carats. This is an excellent ring for those wanting something understated. What’s more, the unobtrusive prongs grant excellent visibility to the center diamond.

7. Large Double Halo Emerald Ring

Large Emerald Ring With Two Surrounding Diamond Halos

Price: $9,000

If you want a piece that is sure to grab everyone’s attention, then consider this large double-halo emerald ring.

The vivid natural Colombian emerald sits in a bezel and has a low profile, while two diamond halos surround it. The square-cut emerald weighs approximately 1.52 carats and the total diamond weight is approximately 0.60 carats. Finally, several small diamonds adorn each shoulder while gorgeous hand-engraved patterns decorate the gallery and the sides of the shoulders.

8. Openwork Marquise Ring

Marquise Shaped Ring With Starburst Openwork Patterned Face

Price: $4,000

Handcrafted in platinum circa 1900, this Edwardian-era marquise ring is certainly suited for brides with a strong personality as it is quite bold and unique itself. The face of this ring is a mesmerizing openwork pattern. Along this elegant face in each cardinal direction sits a single round diamond, while in the center there is a larger round diamond of 0.30 carats, I color, and VS2 clarity.

9. Emerald Cut Diamond Ring With Halo

Emerald Cut Diamond Ring With Diamond Halo

Price: $6,000

The emerald-cut center diamond of this geometric diamond halo ring weighs approximately 0.71 carats and is GIA-certified. A 14-stone diamond halo surrounds the bezel-set center diamond. The tapered shoulders are adorned with an additional diamond each and lead to an elegant triple-wire shank. Finally, fine milgrain borders border the shoulders, center diamond, and halo. 

10. Diamond Ring With Geometric Shoulders

Diamond Ring With Six Diamonds On Each Shoulder

Price: $13,000

This striking diamond ring features unique geometric shoulders and a stunning center diamond. The old European-cut center diamond is GIA-certified as 1.14 carats, H color, and VS1 clarity. On either side, the base of a six-stone pyramid of baguette diamonds extends to the plain shank on either side. Finally, this platinum ring has a total diamond weight of 1.50 carats.

11. Deep Green Emerald Ring

Large Deep Green Emerald Ring With Diamond Halo

Price: $19,000

Up next, this bold ring features a striking halo design and a deep green emerald. The natural emerald weighs approximately 4.32 carats. The surrounding diamond halo is comprised of several sections bordered with fine milgrain detailing. Then, each of the tapered shoulders features an additional diamond in a drop-shaped bezel. Finally, bold openwork patterns decorate the under gallery.

12. Double Halo Aquamarine Ring

Large Aquamarine Ring With Sapphire And Diamond Halos

Price: $3,800

If your bride loves the color blue, then this bold double halo ring is an excellent fit.

Traditionally engagement rings feature a center diamond, and while this ring certainly has these magnificent stones, it features a different center gem. Instead, in the spotlight is a 1.97-carat, Asscher-cut aquamarine. Surrounding the center stone is a sapphire halo followed by a 0.51-carat halo of round brilliant-cut diamonds. 

13. Fancy Diamond Ring With Starburst Halo

Orange Yellow Diamond Ring With Starburst Diamond Halo

Price: $9,000

This stunning ring is 18k yellow gold on platinum and features a distinct starburst halo. The 0.70-carat, cushion-cut fancy center diamond is GIA-certified. This unique orange-yellow stone is surrounded by a 1.35-carat series of marquise and pear-shaped diamonds. This ring is the perfect combination of elegance and charm, and the unique shape and color of the ring make it even more special.

14. Emerald Cut Aquamarine Ring

Aquamarine Ring With Sapphire Halo And Diamonds

Price: $5,200

If you find blue sapphires and aquamarines appealing, then consider this gorgeous ring.

The 3.05-carat, emerald-cut center aquamarine is paired with a 0.72-carat halo of dark blue French-cut natural sapphires. Additionally, the 0.20-carat baguette-cut diamond set on each side of the main stone enhances the blue stones by creating a color contrast. Finally, the tapered shoulders are adorned with three additional diamonds each.

15. Large Geometric Ring

Large Diamond Ring With Square Halo And Triangular Shoulders

Price: $22,000

This stunning ring certainly lives up to the Art Deco style as it features boldly patterned geometry. Handcrafted in platinum circa 1935, this bold Art Deco piece features a round 1.75-carat center diamond surrounded by a square halo comprised of 16 square-shaped diamonds. Finally, additional diamonds adorn the large triangular shoulders.

16. Elongated Emerald Ring

Elongated Emerald Ring With Diamond Halo And Gold Bezel

Price: $5,000

This ring is a perfect fit for brides who adore emeralds and elongated rings. The 1.94-carat center emerald is set in an 18k yellow gold bezel and surrounded by a halo of old European-cut diamonds. What’s more, additional diamonds adorn the shoulders. Finally, the total diamond weight is approximately 0.68 carats.

17. Aquamarine Ring With Pavé Diamonds

Dainty Aquamarine Ring With Pave Set Diamonds

Price: $2,800

The Asscher cut and color of the aquamarine stone on this ring is so exquisite that the stone resembles a teardrop – of happiness, of course. A pavé-set diamonds run along the shoulders and gallery while the visible part of the shank is decorated with fine engravings. The total carat weight of the diamonds is approximately 0.36 while the impressive aquamarine is approximately 1.39.

18. Charming Kunzite Ring

Emerald Cut Kunzite Ring With Two Diamond Accents

Price: $10,000

This Kunzite ring is perfect for brides who want something charming and unique. The 9.00-carat center stone is held in four double prongs and displays a stunning vivid pink color. Then, a trapezoid cut diamond flanks each side totaling 0.77 carats. Finally, the platinum band is subtle and unadorned, which suits this delicate piece quite well. 

19. Gold Art Nouveau Ring

Yellow Gold Ring With Seven Diamonds And Engraved Shoulders

Price: $5,500

Handcrafted in 18k yellow gold circa 1890, this luxurious Art Nouveau ring features seven old mine-cut diamonds with a total weight of 1.05 carats. The overall color and clarity grades are I-J and VS1-SI1 respectively. The shoulders feature leaf motif engravings and meet at the center of the ring at such an angle that they create a swirling effect.

20. Onyx Diamond Ring 

Round Diamond Ring With Black Onyx Halo

Price: $15,500

We love onyx because of the excellent effect it has in concert with diamonds – this ring is here to demonstrate. The center stone is a traditional, 1.24-carat, old European-cut diamond. But the halo around it is made from glossy black buffed onyx. Finally, a bullet-shaped diamond accent sits on each shoulder. If you’re looking for the ultimate color contrast, then consider this striking ring.

21. Aquamarine Ring With Emerald Halo

Aquamarine Ring With Emerald Halo And Diamond Accents

Price: $6,000

The design of this aquamarine ring isn’t uncommon, yet this tri-color ring is nonetheless eye-catching. The center emerald-cut aquamarine weighs 3.22 carats, while the surrounding emerald halo is approximately 0.70 carats. Last, but not least, several diamonds make an appearance- on each side, a single baguette diamond leads to the subtly tapered shoulder with three additional diamonds.

22. Square Emerald Ring

Square Emerald Ring With Diamond Halo

Price: $6,000

This ring features a square face and a delicate band. The center stone is a 1.84-carat emerald-cut emerald set in an 18k yellow gold bezel. 22 Pavé-set diamonds form a surrounding halo, while four additional diamonds are pavé-set along each shoulder. The gold and green pairing evokes a regal feel and is a color combination that is certainly pleasing to the eye.

23. Subtle Solitaire Ring

White Gold Ring With A Single Diamond In Prongs

Price: $9,000

Handcrafted in 18k white gold circa 1980, this Retro ring has a very minimal and charming style. The 1.29-carat, old European-cut diamond is set in four double prongs. If you want a minimal solitaire diamond ring, then definitely keep an eye on this one.

24. Floral Diamond Cluster Ring

Platinum On Yellow Gold Diamond Cluster Ring

Price: $7,000

The nine diamonds of this spectacular ring form a shining flower. This platinum-on-yellow gold piece features a 0.76-carat center diamond with J color and VS2 clarity. What’s more, the alluring spearhead shoulders hold additional diamonds and are decorated with fine milgrain.

25. Art Deco Diamond Ring

Price: $8,600

Handcrafted in platinum circa 1920, this Art Deco ring features an old European-cut center diamond of 1.27 carats, K color, and VS2 clarity. A diamond-set marquise bezel bridges the gap between the center stone and each shoulder, creating a remarkable arrangement of shapes.

26. Crown Style Ring

Yellow Gold Diamond Ring With Crown Style Setting

Price: $18,000

Brides who prefer the classics will definitely love this 18k yellow gold crown-style ring. The 1.63-carat center diamond is GIA-certified and set in an absolutely stunning crown setting. The setting itself is decorated by fleur-de-lis patterns adorned with diamonds. Four smaller diamonds run along each of the shoulders, and are bordered with fine milgrain.

27. Emerald Cut Kunzite Ring

Emerald Cut Kunzite Ring With Two Accent Diamonds

Price: $4,500

If you were hoping to see more kunzite options on this list, then this piece is here to make your hopes come true.

This chic ring features angular shapes and is a great example of the Art Deco style. The emerald-cut, 2.14-carat center kunzite is flanked on each side by a trapezoid diamond totaling 0.40 carats. All three stones are held in prongs, while the remainder of this platinum ring is unembellished further.

28. Floral Halo Ring

Price: $9,500

Seeing a photo of this ring doesn’t do it justice as the unique setting style reveals itself at certain perspectives.

This stunning vintage ring features an exceptionally rare colorless 1.42-carat center diamond. It would be a shame if such a rare and impressive stone was not made as visible as possible- and thankfully, the unique setting of this ring ensures maximum visibility. Not only that, the base of the setting is set with a halo of smaller diamonds, further emphasizing the spectacular setting and diamond.

29. Octagonal Onyx Halo Ring

White Gold Diamond Ring With Black Onyx Halo

Price: $45,000

If you’re searching for the ultimate color contrast, then search no further. Handcrafted in 18k white gold circa 1925, this Art Deco piece features a 4.30-carat cushion-cut center diamond set in a bezel. The surrounding black onyx provides the most striking contrast against the enveloped white diamond.

30. Tiffany & Co. Ring

Price: $4,500

Wrapping up our list, this charming ring has excellent sparkle appeal. The cushion-cut pink sapphire weighs 1.11 carats and is set in bold prongs that are very much integral to the overall design. Then, round brilliant-cut diamonds are set along the shoulders, around the sapphire, and along the gallery. Finally, the total diamond weight of this 18k white gold ring is approximately 1.16 carats.

Trendy Vintage Engagement Rings

Ben and customer at vintage jewelry showroom

Fashion is cyclic – for this reason, plenty of Vintage Engagement Rings Etsy pieces fit modern trends. Thankfully, nowadays you can select an engagement ring style you prefer without worrying about breaking the rules. Whether you like a 16-carat kunzite ring or a modest three-stone diamond ring, we hope that the ring you choose will bring your significant other a lot of joy.

If you have any questions or are interested in learning more about any of our pieces, then please feel free to fill out the contact form below.