Jewelry Blog

Top 30 Second-Hand Engagement Rings

Customer Trying on Vintage Engagement Ring on Finger

Second-hand engagement rings, including vintage, antique, and estate rings, can be an excellent choice. Firstly, second-hand engagement rings are rare, so you’re assured a one-of-a-kind piece. Secondly, they have more personality and tend to have a rich history behind them. And finally, second-hand engagement rings are cut by hand rather than produced by machines. As such, they tend to be of a much higher quality. Indeed, these rings are carefully fashioned by artisans skilled in various areas like pavé setting, engravings, and fine milgrain. Most importantly of all, they’re beautiful, elegant, and timeless. Let’s dig in a bit deeper as we go over the top 30 second-hand engagement rings.

1. Allentown Ring

White Gold Diamond Engagement Ring With Accent Diamonds

Price: $4,000. Learn more about the Allentown Ring.

Beginning our second-hand engagement rings list, the Allentown Ring is a stunning retro-era engagement ring featuring a 0.50-carat old European-cut diamond with I color and VS2 clarity. Single-cut diamonds flank the center stone weighing 0.07 carats in total. Finally, the curved mounting is handcrafted in 18k white gold.

2. Madrid Ring

Delicate Diamond Engagement Ring With Floral Diamond Halo

Price: $5,700. Learn more about the Madrid Ring

This halo-style platinum ring features a sparkling 0.92-carat old European-cut center diamond set in prongs. Surrounding the J color and VS2 clarity center stone is a floral halo of diamonds separated by the prongs. What’s more, additional pavé-set diamonds adorn the shoulders bringing the total weight of the additional diamonds to approximately 0.22 carats.

3. The Denmark Ring

Square Ring Featuring Diamonds And Sapphires

Price: $9,500. Learn more about The Denmark Ring.

This gorgeous handcrafted platinum ring is a one-of-a-kind, eye-catching piece. Intricate openwork decorates the gallery, while fine milgrain details emphasize each element of the ring. The round 1.23-carat center diamond has J color and SI1 clarity. French-cut sapphires and brilliant-cut diamonds surround the stone, filling in the square-shaped body of the ring.

4. Calabria Ring

Delicate Ring With Large Diamond And Many Smaller Diamonds

Price: $25,000. Learn more about the Calabria Ring.

This spectacular piece features a large rose-cut center diamond set in prongs, weighing 2.69 carats. This GIA-certified stone has K color and VS2 clarity. Designed to impress, the ring is decorated with micro-pavé round brilliant-cut diamonds along the under gallery, shank, and prongs.

5. Norfolk Ring

Elongated Three Stone Sapphire Ring With Floral Diamond Halo

Price: $11,500. Learn more about the Norfolk Ring.

Set in a North-South orientation, this elongated Edwardian-era ring features three sapphires weighing approximately 1.00 carat in total. The sapphires are surrounded by a dazzling floral halo of antique cushion-cut diamonds.

6. Cartier Engagement Ring

Diamond Studded Gold Ring With Oval Center Diamond

Price: $8,800. Learn more about the Cartier Engagement Ring.

This yellow gold ring features a 0.50-carat oval center diamond with G color and VS1 clarity. What’s more, many additional diamonds line the body of the ring in three rows bringing the total diamond weight to 1.62 carats. A rare piece made in France circa 1995, it was signed and numbered by Cartier.

7. Columbus Ring

Thin Ring With Large Diamond And Small Diamond Accents

Price: $42,000. Learn more about the Columbus Ring.

This stunning engagement ring features a GIA-certified 3.21-carat rose cushion-cut diamond with K color and VS1 clarity. The diamond sits in a four-prong setting, while diamond accents line the prongs. Micro-pavé round brilliant-cut diamonds adorn the platinum shank, while additional diamonds adorn the gallery.

8. Mirage Ring

Platinum And Yellow Gold Ring With Swirling Diamond Halo

Price: $9,200. Learn more about the Mirage Ring.

This elegant ring features a 1.13-carat old European-cut center diamond with I color and VS2 clarity held in the center of a swirling halo. The halo is formed from a ribbon of pavé-set single-cut diamonds extending from each shoulder. What’s more, they are embellished with fine milgrain borders. Finally, this ring was handcrafted in platinum on 18k yellow gold.

9. Adelaide Ring

Platinum Three Stone Ruby Ring With Diamond Halo

Price: $2,200. Learn more about the Adelaide Ring.

Featuring three oval cut rubies set in an east-west orientation, this Edwardian-inspired ring is sure to delight. The rubies weigh 0.75 carats in total and are surrounded by a halo of round brilliant-cut diamonds. The platinum shank is subtle and unadorned.

10. Califon Ring

Charming White Gold Diamond Ring Featuring Various Shapes

Price: $2,500. Learn more about the Califon Ring.

This delicate beauty was handcrafted in 14k white gold circa 1945, during the retro era. It features a center 0.40-carat box prong-set center diamond with H color and VS1 clarity. Each shoulder features single-cut diamonds set in rounded triangles.

11. Middletown Ring

Diamond Ring Covered In Fine Milgrain And Additional Diamonds

Price: $15,800. Learn more about the Middletown Ring.

Handcrafted in platinum circa 1910, this spectacular Edwardian era piece features a 1.87-carat old European-cut center diamond with K color and VS2 clarity. The shoulders and gallery feature additional small diamonds, while openwork and fine milgrain embellish the ring further.

What’s more, adorning the shank are intricate geometrical hand engravings that are found on all sides and continue to the bottom. This unique and stunning ring certainly reflects the romanticism and design of the Edwardian era.

12. Rochdale Ring

Dainty Platinum Diamond Ring With Shoulder Diamonds

Price: $9,500. Learn more about the Rochdale Ring.

This dainty platinum ring features a GIA-certified 1.08-carat old European-cut diamond with J color and VS2 clarity. A baguette-cut diamond flanks the prong-set center stone on each shoulder. It resembles a Tiffany-style ring, simplistic and beautiful.

13. The Derby Ring

Art Deco Era 0.65ct Center Old European Cut Diamond French Engagement Ring - Derby Ring - Hand Video

Price: $3,200. Learn more about The Derby Ring.

Inspired by the geometric shapes embraced during the Art Deco period, this delicate piece is sure to appeal to lovers of this subtle and unique style. The 0.65-carat center diamond has J color and VS2 clarity. Most notably, the prongs contribute to the ring’s unique shape. Finally, the shoulders are adorned with additional diamonds.

14. Yorkshire Ring

Platinum On Yellow Gold Floral Diamond Cluster Ring

Price: $7,000. Learn more about the Yorkshire Ring.

This cluster diamond ring features a 0.76-carat center diamond of J color and VS2 clarity. A floral cluster of old European-cut diamonds surrounds the center diamond. Cluster-shaped diamonds were fashionable in the Edwardian era. Finally, the ring is handcrafted in platinum on yellow gold.

15. Elliston Ring

18k Yellow Gold Natural Round Aquamarine Engagement Ring - Elliston Ring - Hand Video

Price: $1,800. Learn more about the Elliston Ring.

This small, delicate 18k yellow gold engagement ring features a 0.72-carat center aquamarine set-in prongs. The leaf motif shoulders enhance the center stone, granting additional charm to the design. What’s more, a small diamond adorns each leaf; that’s six sparkling white stones to add emphasize the aquamarine and yellow gold setting.

16. Aden Ring

Diamond Cluster Platinum Engagement Ring With Minimal Design

Price: $2,000. Learn more about the Aden Ring.

Handcrafted in platinum during the Art Deco era (Circa 1925), this cluster ring features a minimal design but certainly retains a dazzling appeal. The center diamond is what shines brightest, featuring a surrounding cluster of old European-cut diamonds totaling 0.72 carats. Finally, the stones are J color and VS2-S12 clarity overall.

17. Amiens Ring

Double Diamond Halo Ring Featuring Pink Center Sapphire

Price: $3,500. Learn more about the Amiens Ring.

Featuring a double halo of old mine-cut diamonds and a vivid pink oval center sapphire, the Amiens was handcrafted circa 1870, during the Victorian era. What’s more, additional diamonds line the shoulders. The total sapphire and diamond weights are 0.40 and 1.55 carats respectively. Finally, this ring features silver on 14k yellow gold.

18. Avalon Ring

Wide Five Diamond Ring With Sapphire Halo

Price: $3,200. Learn more about the Avalon Ring.

The spectacular Avalon Ring features a row of five round brilliant-cut diamonds set in an east-west orientation. They total 0.50 carats and have I color and VS1 clarity overall. What’s more, a 0.75-carat halo of French-cut natural sapphires surrounds the diamonds, conforming to their combined rounded shape.

Finally, this platinum beauty features openwork patterns decorating the gallery as well as fine milgrain bordering the diamonds and sapphires.

19. Beckton Ring

Platinum Ring Featuring Large Diamond Held In Eight Prongs

Price: $72,000. Learn more about the Beckton Ring.

If you have a more lenient budget, then you will certainly want to check out this absolutely stunning Art Deco engagement ring.

The 4.25-carat old European-cut center diamond has K color and VS1 clarity. Then, the crown-style setting features fleur-de-lis designs, while the diamonds that run along the shoulders provide extra sparkle. Handcrafted in platinum circa 1930, this is perfect for those wanting a large diamond and a subtle, regal design.

20. Bellevue Ring

Three Stone Diamond Engagement Ring With Fine Milgrain

Price: $6,000. Learn more about the Bellevue Ring.

This stunning platinum ring features a three-stone design and smaller diamonds adorning the shoulders. The central diamonds run east to west and total 1.16 carats, with J-K color and VS2-SI1 clarity overall. This piece is certainly elegant, classy, and made to shine.

21. Brookhaven Ring

3.52ct Center Emerald Cut Emerald and French Cut Diamond Ring - Brookhaven Ring - Hand Video

Price: $13,000. Learn more about the Brookhaven Ring.

This ring has elegance and class written all over it. The stylish Brookhaven features a 3.52-carat emerald-cut emerald set-in prongs. What’s more, French-cut diamonds are set in rectangular bezels on both sides of the center stone, creating geometric step-down pattern shoulders and totaling 0.96 carats. Finally, this handcrafted platinum ring is decorated with fine milgrain details.

22. Brunswick Ring

Vertically Elongated Silver And Yellow Gold Three Stone Diamond Ring

Price: $2,700. Learn more about the Brunswick Ring.

If you’re looking for something that has a more antique feel, then check out the Georgian-era Brunswick Ring. Three rose-cut diamonds are set in a vertically elongated silver on yellow gold mounting and total 0.30 carats. What’s more, additional rose-cut diamonds surround the center stones, while hand engravings decorate the shoulders and shank.

23. Cannes Ring

Three Stone Platinum Ring Featuring A Sapphire And Diamonds

Price: $6,800. Learn more about the Cannes Ring.

This minimal and sophisticated three-stone Art Deco ring features a 1.05-carat cushion-cut sapphire flanked by two old European-cut diamonds. Each diamond is 0.20 carats and they have J color and SI1-SI2 clarity overall. The remainder of the platinum mounting is unadorned, making this stylish ring perfect for those who don’t want an overcomplicated ring.

24. Chaumont Ring

Edwardian Era Pearl & Old Mine Cut Diamond Leaf Motif Three Stone Ring - Chaumont Ring - Hand Video

Price: $3,500. Learn more about the Chaumont Ring.

If you’re looking for an elegant and classy piece, then consider this pearl-centered French Edwardian era engagement ring. Diamonds are set diagonally, while the diamond-adorned shoulders twist to surround the pearl. Finally, this platinum on 18k yellow gold ring has a total diamond weight of 0.58 carats.

25. Jersey Ring

Platinum And Yellow Gold Ring Featuring Diamonds

Price: $3,200. Learn more about the Jersey Ring.

Handcrafted in platinum on 18k yellow gold circa 1910, this French Edwardian piece is certainly a treasure. Firstly, the 0.45-carat center diamond boasts G color and VS2 clarity. Then, the shoulders are lined with three additional diamonds each. Finally, the eight-prong setting doubles as a metal halo which serves well to enhance the center diamond.

26. Blairstown Ring

Delicate Diamond Ring With Step Down Diamond Shoulders

Price: $4,800. Learn more about the Blairstown Ring.

If you’re looking for a stunning and delicate diamond ring, then look no further than the Blairstown. Handcrafted in platinum circa 1925, this Art Deco beauty features a 0.70-carat center diamond with impressive I color and VS2 clarity grades. What’s more, the diamond-adorned shoulders feature a step-down design to give this charming piece some added depth.

27. Berge Ring

13495 Top Cool Engagement Rings

Price: $4,000. Learn more about the Berge Ring.

If you are considering more unique options, but don’t want something that is too “out there”, then consider the tamed yet special Berge Ring.

Handcrafted in platinum circa 1940, this Retro era piece leverages a unique confluence of shapes. Firstly, the sleek and square body holds a 0.60-carat round center diamond set in box prongs. Then, two rows of pavé-set rose-cut diamonds flank the center stone on either side.

28. Ambroise Ring

Diamond And Blue Sapphire Checkered Ring

Price: $3,200. Learn more about the Ambroise Ring.

The Ambroise Ring offers a unique sapphire and diamond checkered design; it’s certainly no surprise that this is an Art Deco piece. Single-cut diamonds and French-cut synthetic sapphires comprise the mesmerizing pattern, totaling 0.35 and 0.40 carats respectively. Finally, the shoulders of this platinum on 18k gold beauty feature a bold leaf pattern.

29. Dartmouth Ring

Diamond Ring With Many Intricate And Luxurious Details

Price: $13,500. Learn more about the Dartmouth Ring.

This spectacular ring was handcrafted in platinum circa 1915, during the Edwardian era. The 1.48-carat old European-cut center diamond has K color and VS2 clarity, while its leaf-motif prongs enhance it greatly. What’s more, the exquisite ornamentation doesn’t stop there; additional diamonds, scroll motif openwork, and crossed ribbon shoulders are just a few of the additional details that elevate this piece.

30. Athens Ring

4.59ct Center Old European Cut Diamond Dome Filigree Engagement Ring - Athens Ring - Hand Video

Price: $59,000. Learn more about the Athens Ring.

This bold dome-style ring showcases a stunning 4.59-carat old European-cut diamond of L color and VS1 clarity. Not only is the center diamond spectacular, but the body of the ring itself is a spectacle in its own right; columns of additional diamonds extending throughout the entirety of the ring are buffered by delicate milgrain and openwork.

Talk to a Diamond Expert

Afshin in showroom with customer

Second-hand engagement rings feature so many different styles, tastes, and price points you’re bound to find something that suits your needs. Speak with a diamond expert at Estate Diamond Jewelry for one-on-one guidance. We’ll answer any questions, offer insight, and ultimately help you on this special journey. Rely on us to consider your needs and preferences while respecting your budget. Whether you want to inquire about second-hand engagement rings, or something else, simply complete the contact form below to get started.

author-avatar

About Benjamin Khordipour

Benjamin Khordipour is one of the jewelry researchers and gemologists at Estate Diamond Jewelry. He received his official gemological degrees from both the GIA and GUBELIN. He also regularly contributes to Business Insider, Forbes, Rapaport, CNBC, and Brides Magazine. Benjamin was born in New York and joined Estate Diamond Jewelry in 2014. He is passionate about vintage jewelry and diamonds. This blog was built on his strong belief that jewelers have a responsibility to properly educate their customers. In 2019, Benjamin co-authored the book The Engagement Ring Guide for Men. His favorite vintage jewelry era is the Art Deco Era and his favorite type of stone is the Kashmir Sapphire. He also collects rare antique pins.